Kampf der Festivals

[wolf!]

Ich machs jetzt mal nach Sh03s-T´s Prinzip

Rock Im Park:

Spoiler

Kings Of Leon 5
Wolfmother 5
System Of A Down 5
Alesana 4
Rob Zombie 4
The Kooks 4
3 Doors Down 4
Korn 4
Escape The Fate 4
Coldplay 4
Disturbed 3
The Devil Wears Prada 3
Interpol 3
Hollywood Undead 3
Bring Me The Horizon 3
Alter Bridge 3
Simple Plan 3
Beatsteaks 3
Mando Diao 3
Volbeat 3
Mastodon 2
Architects 2
We Are Scientists 2
Times Of Grace 2
And You Will Know Us.... 2
Royal Republic 2
Neon Trees 2
White Lies 2
August Burns Red 2
Avenged Sevenfold 2
Social Distortion 2
Asking Alexandria 2
All That Remains 2
The Gaslight Anthem 2
Hurts 2
In Flames 2
Madsen 1
The Naked And Famous 1
Söhne Mannheims 1
Framing Hanley 1
Selig 0
The Boss Hoss 0

109 Punkte
Durchschnitt: 2,60

 

[arm3nia]

Hab' mal Fabus' Idee übernommen und beim Schnitt zwischen "wichtigen" und "unwichtigen" Bands unterschieden. :)

Rock im Park:

Spoiler

5 Punkte:
System of a Down
4 Punkte:
Architects
August Burns Red
Bring Me The Horizon
Disturbed
In Flames
Korn
3 Punkte:
Alesana
All That Remains
Alter Bridge
Asking Alexandria
Escape The Fate
The Devil Wears Prada
Times Of Grace
2 Punkte:
3 Doors Down
Avenged Sevenfold
Beatsteaks
Framing Hanley
Mastodon
Rob Zombie
1 Punkt:
...And You Will Know Us By The Trail Of Dead
Hollywood Undead
Simple Plan
Social Distortion
Volbeat
0 Punkte:
Coldplay
Duff McKagan’s Loaded
Hurts
Interpol
Kings Of Leon
Madsen
Mando Diao
Neon Trees
Royal Republic
Selig
Söhne Mannheims
The BossHoss
The Gaslight Anthem
The Kooks
The Naked And Famous
We Are Scientists
White Lies
Wolfmother

67 Punkte | Schnitt 0-5: 1,56 | Schnitt 1-5: 2,68

With Full Force:

Spoiler

5 Punkte:
Ill Nino
4 Punkte:
Bullet For My Valentine
Bring Me The Horizon
Emil Bulls
Parkway Drive
3 Punkte:
Cavalera Conspiracy
Hatebreed
Hellyeah
More Than A Thousand
Samael
Suicide Silence
The Black Dahlia Murder
The Casualties
The Ghost Inside
2 Punkte:
50 Lions
Agnostic Front
Arma Gathas
Blood For Blood
Carnifex
Deez Nuts
Evile
Grave
Kvelertak
Kylesa
Legion Of The Damned
Madball
Misery Index
Negator
Terror
Watain
Your Demise
1 Punkt:
Deadlock
Death By Stereo
Satyricon
Six Feet Under
Volbeat
0 Punkte:
Arkona
Die Apokalyptischen Reiter
Die Kassierer
Knorkator
Krawallbrüder
Mad Sin
Manos
Moonspell
Omnium Gatherum
Peter Pan Speedrock
The Adolescents
U.S. Bombs

87 Punkte | Schnitt 0-5: 1,81 | Schnitt 1-5: 2,42


Wacken:

Spoiler

5 Punkte:
4 Punkte:
Children Of Bodom
Heaven Shall Burn
Sepultura
Trivium
3 Punkte:
As I Lay Dying
Cradle Of Filth
Devil Driver
Hellsaw
Mayhem
2 Punkte:
Accuser
Apocalyptica
Blowsight
Exodus
Hail Of Bullets
Kataklysm
Khold
Kreator
Morbid Angel
Morgoth
Negator
Shining
Shraphead
Skálmöld
Sodom
Suicidal Tendencies
Suidakra
Tauthr
The Haunted
The Prophecy 23
Torture Squad
Vreid
1 Punkt:
Bülent Ceylan
Motörhead
0 Punkte:
Airbourne
Avantasia
Battle Beast
Blaas Of Glory
Blind Guardian
Bullet
CrashDiet
Eläkeläiset
Excrementory Grindfuckers
Hayseed Dixie
Hämatom
Helloween
Horch
Iced Earth
In Solitude
Judas Priest
Knorkator
Onslaught
Ozzy Osbourne
Pharao
Primal Fear
Rhapsody Of Fire
Russkaja
Saltatio Mortis
Sirenia
Ski King
Stier
Stormzone
Subway To Sally
The Aberlours
The Smackballz
Tokyo Blade
Triosphere
Tsjuder
Venomin James
Victims Of Madness
Visions Of Atlantis
Volcano
Warrant

72 Punkte | Schnitt 0-5: 1,07 | Schnitt 1-5: 2,33

Fazit:
Rock im Park bleibt das wichtigste Festival, da es in der Spitze einfach deutlich besser besetzt ist als die Konkurrenz.
Das WFF sticht Wacken aktuell klar aus, da es ein viiiiel besseres Mittelfeld auffahren kann.

 

[Badoutzzz]

Rock im Park: 96 Punkte; Schnitt 2,23

Spoiler

3 Doors Down 1
Alesana 0
All That Remains 0
Alter Bridge 0
...And You Will Know Us By The Trail Of Dead 4
Architects 0
Asking Alexandria 0
August Burns Red 0
Avenged Sevenfold 0
Beatsteaks 4
Bring Me The Horizon 0
Coldplay 4
Disturbed 1
Duff McKagan’s Loaded 2
Escape The Fate 0
Framing Hanley 0
Hollywood Undead 0
Hurts 2
In Flames 1
Interpol 3
Kings Of Leon 3
Korn 0
Madsen 3
Mando Diao 1
Mastodon 4
Neon Trees 0
Rob Zombie 1
Royal Republic 3
Selig 1
Simple Plan 1
Social Distortion 3
Söhne Mannheims 0
System Of A Down 3
The BossHoss 0
The Devil Wears Prada 0
The Gaslight Anthem 4
The Kooks 4
The Naked And Famous 4
Times Of Grace 0
Volbeat 2
We Are Scientists 3
White Lies 3
Wolfmother 4

HuSo: 92 Punkte; Schnitt 2,48

Spoiler

Foo Fighters 4
Blink-182 2
Arcade Fire 5
The Chemical Brothers 3
Portishead 5
Arctic Monkeys 4
Clueso 0
The Hives 4
The Subways 3
Gogol Bordello 3
Flogging Molly 3
Elbow 3
The Wombats 3
Sublime With Rome 2
Two Door Cinema Club 2
Boysetsfire 4
Selig 2
Band Of Horses 5
The Sounds 3
Klaxons 2
Eels 4
Sick Of It All 0
Parkway Drive 0
William Fitzsimmons 3
I Am Kloot 3
Friendly Fires 1
Darwin Deez 1
Converge 3
Comeback Kid 0
Portugal. The Man 4,5
Kvelertak 4
You Me At Six 0
Brother 0
Cloud Control 0
MSTRKRFT 4
Frittenbude 1
Egotronic 1

 

[nitsche]

Ohne punkte einfach in Wortform: Der Park stinkt übelst ab dieses Jahr.

 

[sunset]

Rock im Park 67

Spoiler

Madsen 1
Wolfmother 3
The Naked And Famous 4
Alesana 0
Mastodon 0
Disturbed 3
Söhne Mannheims 0
Architects 0
We Are Scientists 1
Times Of Grace 0
System Of A Down 5
And You Will Know Us.... 0
Royal Republic 2
Rob Zombie 1
The Kooks 3
Neon Trees 0
3 Doors Down 4
The Devil Wears Prada 0
White Lies 1
August Burns Red 0
Avenged Sevenfold 0
Kings Of Leon 3
Interpol 1
Social Distortion 4
Framing Hanley 0
Hollywood Undead 0
Selig 3
Korn 1
Bring Me The Horizon 2
Alter Bridge 3
Asking Alexandria 0
Simple Plan 3
All That Remains 1
Escape The Fate 1
The Gaslight Anthem 3
Beatsteaks 4
Coldplay 5
Volbeat 4
Hurts 0
In Flames 0
The Boss Hoss 1
Mando Diao 0

Southside 56

Spoiler

Foo Fighters 5
Blink-182 5
The Chemical Brothers 3
The Wombats 0
Two Door Cinema Club 1
Sick Of It All 1
Parkway Drive 0
William Fitzsimmons 0
Friendly Fires 0
Darwin Deez 0
Converge 0
Comeback Kid 0
Kvelertak 0
Frittenbude 4
Egotronic 0
Arcade Fire 5
Portishead 2
Arctic Monkeys 4
The Hives 3
Gogol Bordello 3
Flogging Molly 3
Elbow 0
The Sounds 4
Band of Horses 0
Brother 0
Boysetsfire 3
Cloud Control 0
Clueso 3
Eels 0
I Am Kloot 0
Klaxons 0
MSTRKRFT 0
Portugal. The Man 0
Selig 3
Sublime With Rome 0
The Subways 3
You Me At Six 1

Fazit: Park hat sich mit der letzten Welle stark verbessert für mich! Ticket ist zu 95% gekauft ;)

 

[Lucifer[93]]

Rock im Park:

Spoiler

5 Punkte:
System of a Down
4 Punkte:
Disturbed
In Flames
Korn
Alter Bridge
Avenged Sevenfold
Rob Zombie
Volbeat
3 Punkte:
Bring Me The Horizon
Wolfmother
Madsen
2 Punkte:
All That Remains
Escape The Fate
The Devil Wears Prada
Times Of Grace
The BossHoss
Architects
3 Doors Down
Beatsteaks
Framing Hanley
Mastodon
...And You Will Know Us By The Trail Of Dead
Selig
1 Punkt:
Asking Alexandria
August Burns Red
Hollywood Undead
Simple Plan
Social Distortion
Coldplay
Alesana
0 Punkte:
Duff McKagan’s Loaded
Hurts
Interpol
Kings Of Leon
Mando Diao
Neon Trees
Royal Republic
Söhne Mannheims
The Gaslight Anthem
The Kooks
The Naked And Famous
We Are Scientists
White Lies

73 Punkte | Gesamtschnitt: 1,74

With Full Force:

Spoiler

5 Punkte:
Ill Nino
Bullet For My Valentine
Parkway Drive
4 Punkte:
Bring Me The Horizon
Emil Bulls
Hatebreed
Deadlock
Volbeat
3 Punkte:
Die Apokalyptischen Reiter
Die Kassierer
Knorkator
Cavalera Conspiracy
Hellyeah
More Than A Thousand
Samael
Suicide Silence
The Black Dahlia Murder
The Casualties
The Ghost Inside
2 Punkte:
50 Lions
Agnostic Front
Arma Gathas
Blood For Blood
Carnifex
Deez Nuts
Evile
Grave
Kvelertak
Kylesa
Legion Of The Damned
Madball
Misery Index
Negator
Terror
Watain
Your Demise
1 Punkt:
Death By Stereo
Satyricon
Six Feet Under
0 Punkte:
Arkona
Krawallbrüder
Mad Sin
Manos
Moonspell
Omnium Gatherum
Peter Pan Speedrock
The Adolescents
U.S. Bombs

105 Punkte | Gesamtschnitt: 2,19

Fazit: Momentan klar WFF - Besseres Line-Up - Günstiger

 

[Balnazzar]

RIP (6:

Spoiler

3 Doors Down 2
Alesana 0
All That Remains 4
Alter Bridge 2
...And You Will Know Us By The Trail Of Dead 0
Architects 4
Asking Alexandria 0
August Burns Red 4
Avenged Sevenfold 4
Beatsteaks 2
Bring Me The Horizon 4
Coldplay 0
Disturbed 4
Duff McKagan’s Loaded 0
Escape The Fate 0
Framing Hanley 0
Hollywood Undead 4
Hurts 2
In Flames 4
Interpol 0
Kings Of Leon 0
Korn 4
Madsen 2
Mando Diao 2
Mastodon 2
Neon Trees 0
Rob Zombie 4
Royal Republic 0
Selig 0
Simple Plan 0
Social Distortion 0
Söhne Mannheims 0
System Of A Down 4
The BossHoss 2
The Devil Wears Prada 4
The Gaslight Anthem 0
The Kooks 0
The Naked And Famous 0
Times Of Grace 0
Volbeat 2
We Are Scientists 0
White Lies 0
Wolfmother 2

Southside (22)

Spoiler

Foo Fighters 4
Blink-182 2
The Chemical Brothers 0
The Wombats 0
Two Door Cinema Club 0
Sick Of It All 0
Parkway Drive 4
William Fitzsimmons 0
Friendly Fires 0
Darwin Deez 0
Converge 0
Comeback Kid 0
Kvelertak 0
Frittenbude 4
Egotronic 0
Arcade Fire 0
Portishead 0
Arctic Monkeys 0
The Hives 4
Gogol Bordello
Flogging Molly 4
Elbow 0
The Sounds 0
Band of Horses 0
Brother 0
Boysetsfire 0
Cloud Control 0
Clueso 0
Eels 0
I Am Kloot 0
Klaxons 0
MSTRKRFT 0
Portugal. The Man 0
Selig 0
Sublime With Rome 0
The Subways 0
You Me At Six 0

Also gaaaanz klar RiP

 

[splashdash]

warum nehmen alle eig immer nur RiP und SoSi?

 

[SystemofaDown]

Ohne punkte einfach in Wortform: Der Park stinkt übelst ab dieses Jahr.

word!

 

[einsiedler]

Geil, noch nicht gesehen 4
Geil, schon gesehen 3
Basst schon, noch nicht gesehen 2
Basst schon, schon gesehen 1
Interessiert mich nicht, oder kenn ich nicht 0

RIP (86):

Spoiler

3 Doors Down 4
Alesana 0
All That Remains 0
Alter Bridge 4
...And You Will Know Us By The Trail Of Dead 2
Architects 2
Asking Alexandria 0
August Burns Red 2
Avenged Sevenfold 4
Beatsteaks 4
Bring Me The Horizon 0
Coldplay 4
Disturbed 3
Duff McKagan’s Loaded 2
Escape The Fate 2
Framing Hanley 0
Hollywood Undead 0
Hurts 2
In Flames 1
Interpol 0
Kings Of Leon 4
Korn 2
Madsen 2
Mando Diao 1
Mastodon 4
Neon Trees 0
Rob Zombie 4
Royal Republic 4
Selig 0
Simple Plan 2
Social Distortion 4
Söhne Mannheims 0
System Of A Down 4
The BossHoss 4
The Devil Wears Prada 2
The Gaslight Anthem 2
The Kooks 2
The Naked And Famous 0
Times Of Grace 0
Volbeat 3
We Are Scientists 2
White Lies 0
Wolfmother 4

Southside (36)

Spoiler

Foo Fighters 4
Blink-182 4
The Chemical Brothers 2
The Wombats 0
Two Door Cinema Club 0
Sick Of It All 0
Parkway Drive 0
William Fitzsimmons 0
Friendly Fires 0
Darwin Deez 0
Converge 0
Comeback Kid 0
Kvelertak 4
Frittenbude 0
Egotronic 0
Arcade Fire 2
Portishead 2
Arctic Monkeys 2
The Hives 3
Gogol Bordello 2
Flogging Molly 3
Elbow 0
The Sounds 2
Band of Horses 0
Brother 0
Boysetsfire 2
Cloud Control 0
Clueso 0
Eels 0
I Am Kloot 0
Klaxons 0
MSTRKRFT 0
Portugal. The Man 0
Selig 0
Sublime With Rome 0
The Subways 2
You Me At Six 2

Klare Sache!

 

[SystemofaDown]

Da ich vieles nicht kenne habe ich von beiden die besten 13 gnommen:

Rock im Park:
System of a Down: 4
Coldplay: 0
Kings of Leon: 0
Beatsteaks: 3
Mando Diao: 0
Kooks: 2
Korn: 3
Disturbed: 4
Söhne Mannheims: 0
In Flames: 4
Hollywood Undead: 2
Rob Zombie: 2
Volbeat: 4

Punkte: 28

Nova Rock:
System of a Down: 4
Iron Maiden: 4
Linkin Park: 3
Volbeat: 4
Korn: 3
Flogging Molly: 4
In Flames: 4
Sick of It All: 2
Social Distortion: 2
Broilers: 2
The Sounds: 2
Alter Bridge: 2
Cavalera Conspiracy: 2

Punkte: 38

Preis und Headliner und bisherige Bestätigungen: Fuck RiP und join Nova!

 

[Frankenstolz]

Update:

Rock im Park

Spoiler

…And You Will Know Us By The Trail Of Dead 0
3 Doors Down 0
Alesana 5
All That Remains 5
Alter Bridge 5
Architects 5
Ash 0
Asking Alexandria 5
August Burns Red 5
Avenged Sevenfold 5
Beatsteaks 5
Black Stone Cherry 5
Black Veil Brides 5
Bonaparte 0
Bring Me The Horizon 5
Chapel Club 0
Coldplay 0
Danzig 5
Deadmau5 0
Disturbed 5
Dredg 0
Duff McKagan’s Loaded 0
Escape The Fate 5
Framing Hanley 5
Frank Turner 0
Funeral For A Friend 5
Hollywood Undead 0
Hurts 0
In Extremo 5
In Flames 5
Interpol 0
Jamaica 0
Kids In Glass Houses 0
Kings Of Leon 0
koRn 5
Lifehouse 5
Lissie 0
Madsen 5
Mando Diao 0
Mastodon 5
Morning Parade 0
Oh, Napoleon 0
Ozark Henry 0
Pete Yorn 0
Plain White T's 0
Rise To Remain 5
Rob Zombie 5
Robert Francis 0
Royal Republic 0
Selig 0
Sevendust 5
Silverstein 0
Simple Plan 0
Social Distortion 5
Söhne Mannheims 0
Stereo MCs 0
System Of A Down 5
The BossHoss 5
The Devil Wears Prada 5
The Gaslight Anthem 0
The King Blues 0
The Kooks 0
The Naked + Famous 0
The Pretty Reckless 5
Thees Uhlmann & Band 0
Times Of Grace 5
Tom Beck 0
VersaEmerge 0
Volbeat 5
Wayne Static 0
We Are Scientists 0
We Butter The Bread With Butter 5
White Lies 0
Wolfmother 5
Yellow Wire 0

160 Punkte

Rock in Concert Open Air

Spoiler

Motörhead 5
Alice Cooper 5
Broilers 5
Danko Jones 5
Misfits 5
D-A-D 5
The Bones 5
9mm - Assi Rock´n´Roll 5
Andy Brings 5
Guns of Moropolis 5
In Extremo 5
Subway to Sally 5
Apokalyptische Reiter 5
Ensiferum 5
Fiddler´s Green 5
Van Canto 5
Varg 5
Wolfchant 5

90 Punke